Roadside Sobriety Tests in Colorado (Field Sobriety Tests)

Police light bar flashing red and blue at night during a traffic stop.
Roadside sobriety tests usually happen at night, on the side of the road, in whatever conditions the stop happens to be in.

If you were arrested for DUI or DWAI in Colorado, there’s a good chance the officer asked you to do roadside sobriety tests first: following a pen with your eyes, walking a line, standing on one leg. Most people call me after it’s already happened, wondering whether they had to do them and whether their performance can be challenged.

I’m Monte Robbins, a Colorado DUI defense lawyer. I’ve been trained in Standardized Field Sobriety Testing using the same NHTSA curriculum Colorado officers learn, so I know how these tests are supposed to be given, and where they go wrong.


Are Roadside Sobriety Tests Mandatory in Colorado?

Generally, no. The Colorado Supreme Court treats roadside sobriety tests as a search. An officer can conduct them only if you voluntarily agree, or if the officer already has probable cause to arrest you for DUI or DWAI (People v. Carlson, 1984). Colorado officers are trained to tell drivers the tests are voluntary before giving them.

A few things to know:

  • An officer can’t physically make you do them. The tests need your cooperation.
  • Declining roadsides is not an Express Consent refusal. Refusing the breath or blood test after an arrest is different: that can cost you your license. See my DUI Test Refusal page.
  • A refusal can sometimes come up at trial. Where the officer already had probable cause before asking, the Colorado Supreme Court upheld a DUI conviction in which the jury heard that the driver declined, even though the officer never warned him a refusal could be used against him. The court left open whether that’s allowed when there’s no probable cause (McGuire v. People, 1988).
  • No Miranda warning is required before roadsides.

Should You Do Them?

Most of my clients come to me after the fact, so this usually isn’t advice I get to give in advance. But in my view, there’s typically little to gain. Roadsides are voluntary, and in practice they mostly build evidence for the prosecution. They’re scored on clues the officer is looking for, often on the side of a road at night, in cold weather, in whatever shoes you happened to be wearing.


The Three Standardized Field Sobriety Tests

Colorado officers are trained to give three “standardized” tests developed by the National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (NHTSA). Each one is scored by counting specific “clues.”

TestWhat you’re asked to doClues the officer looks for
Horizontal Gaze Nystagmus (HGN)Follow a pen or light with your eyes, without moving your headIn each eye: eyes don’t follow smoothly; distinct, sustained jerking at the far side; jerking that starts before the eye reaches 45 degrees (6 clues total)
Walk-and-TurnStand heel-to-toe while listening to instructions, then take 9 heel-to-toe steps on a line, turn a specific way, and take 9 steps back, counting out loudCan’t keep balance during instructions; starts too soon; stops while walking; misses heel-to-toe; steps off the line; uses arms for balance; improper turn; wrong number of steps (8 clues)
One-Leg StandRaise one foot about 6 inches and count “one thousand one, one thousand two…” for 30 secondsSways; uses arms for balance; hops; puts foot down (4 clues)

Here’s the key point: NHTSA’s own manual says the research behind these tests applies only when they’re given and scored in the standardized way. If any element is changed, NHTSA says, the validity of the test may be compromised. That’s the foundation for challenging them.


The “Extra” Tests: Alphabet, Counting, Romberg, and Finger-to-Nose

More and more Colorado officers go beyond the three standardized tests. You may have been asked to:

  • Recite part of the alphabet or count backward. NHTSA’s manual says these techniques have not been scientifically validated.
  • Do the Modified Romberg Balance test: tilt your head back, close your eyes, and estimate 30 seconds. Everyone sways somewhat on this test, sober or not.
  • Touch your finger to your nose. It was one of the original tests studied, but it didn’t make the final three.

None of these is one of the three validated tests, and they don’t have the same standardized scoring, so they deserve less weight than an officer may give them. Some come from drug-recognition training (ARIDE and DRE), which officers use when they suspect marijuana or other drugs.

Vertical Gaze Nystagmus (VGN) is jerking of the eyes when looking up. NHTSA associates it with high doses of alcohol for that person or certain drugs, and says that if VGN appears without HGN, it could be a medical condition.


How Roadside Tests Get Challenged

When I review a DUI, the roadsides are one of the first things I compare against the video. Problems I see often:

  • The body cam doesn’t match the report. The report lists clues the video doesn’t show, or leaves out what went well. See my Body-Worn Camera Evidence page.
  • Bad instructions or demonstrations. The officer skips steps, demonstrates the test wrong, or isn’t clear about what they want.
  • Instruction-stage problems. On the walk-and-turn, “starts too soon” and “can’t keep balance” are clues. But if the officer asks questions or lets the instruction phase drift, those clues aren’t fair.
  • HGN done wrong. Moving the stimulus too fast, holding it at the wrong distance, too few passes, or flashing patrol lights in your eyes.
  • Conditions. A sloped or uneven surface, gravel, wind, cold, poor lighting, or footwear like boots or heels.
  • Medical and physical issues. Injuries, back or leg problems, inner ear conditions, and other balance issues. Officers are trained to ask about medical conditions before the tests; many don’t.
  • The officer’s certification. In Colorado, officers must keep their SFST training current, with update training every two years, to give roadside tests. If an officer’s certification has lapsed, that matters.
  • The decision was already made. Sometimes the officer decided to arrest before the tests began, and the roadsides were just for the report.

The Preliminary Breath Test (PBT)

The small handheld breath device some officers use at the roadside is a preliminary breath test. Colorado law doesn’t let its result be used at trial (C.R.S. 42-4-1301(6)(i)); it’s only used to help the officer decide whether to arrest. It’s not the evidential breath test at the station. For more on breath testing, see my blog post on Colorado DUI breath test rules.


Frequently Asked Questions About Roadside Sobriety Tests in Colorado

Are roadside sobriety tests mandatory in Colorado?

Generally, no. They’re voluntary unless the officer already has probable cause to arrest you. Officers are trained to tell you they’re voluntary.

Can you refuse a field sobriety test in Colorado?

Yes. Declining isn’t an Express Consent refusal and doesn’t by itself cost you your license. But if the officer already had probable cause, the refusal may be mentioned at trial.

What are the three field sobriety tests?

Horizontal gaze nystagmus (the eye test), the walk-and-turn, and the one-leg stand.

Can you get a DUI if you pass the roadside tests?

Yes. An officer can still arrest based on driving, odor, statements, or a breath or blood test. But good performance on video is strong evidence for the defense.

Is the roadside breath test admissible?

No. The preliminary breath test result can’t be used at trial in Colorado.

Do police have to read Miranda rights before roadsides?

No. Miranda warnings aren’t required before roadside sobriety tests.


Talk to a Colorado DUI Lawyer About Your Roadsides

Call me at 303-355-5148 or contact my office for a free consultation. You’ll speak with me, not a staff member.

Client Reviews

An excellent lawyer choice for my son who was charged with driving while his license was revoked. DMV had mistakenly sent (3) letters of revocation to the incorrect address, so I hired Monty to prove that my son never knew his license was revoked. Monty kept me informed at all times as to what was...

Linda

I consulted three other attorneys on my traffic offense in Colorado and none of them thought I could beat it. Then I consulted with Monte Robbins. He not only relieved my warrant without my presence in Colorado, but he got my habitual driving offense reduced to an infraction. I was up against the...

Steve

I hired Monte J. Robbins to represent me. He gave 110% to my case never rushed me off the phone, quick to gather all information regarding my case. Monte is very knowledgeable and helped me out a lot. He kept me informed every step of the way through my case. I was always able to get a hold of him...

Jeremy

Contact Us

  1. 1 Talk to a Lawyer - Not a Case Manager
  2. 2 Get an Honest Assessment of Your Case
  3. 3 Know Your Next Best Step Before You Hang Up
Fill out the contact form or call us at 303-355-5148 to schedule your consultation.

Leave Us a Message

We Accept the Following Credit Cards:

American Express LogoDiscover LogoMastercard LogoVisa Logo